From the Far Left to the Not so Far Past, ETA and the Separatism of the Basque Country in Spain

The Basque separatist organization ETA (Euskadi Ta Askatasuna) has had a tremendous influence on Spain's political climate and has fueled the country's continuous discussion about regional autonomy and self-determination. The ideological position, tactics, and historical background of ETA all contribute to this impact. A complex and multidimensional political environment has been created in Spain as a result of ETA's violent fight for Basque independence, which has shaped a political culture that balances national unity with accommodating demands for further regional autonomy.

Supporting Arguments

Historical Development: The suppression of regional identities and aspirations for self-determination led to the foundation of ETA during Francisco Franco's authoritarian government. The basis for ETA's quest for regional autonomy and Basque independence was established by this historical background.

Violent Strategies: Spain's political culture was significantly impacted by ETA's use of violence and terrorism to further its objectives. It fostered a culture of distrust and terror, which shaped the government's reaction and made security and national unity the main priorities.

Ideological Influence: The ideology of ETA, which has its roots in Basque nationalism and separatists, has helped to sustain a feeling of regional identity and the conviction that certain regions—not just the Basque Country but also Catalonia and other regions—need more autonomy.

Debate over Regional Autonomy: The current discourse in Spain on regional autonomy has been significantly shaped by the acts and demands of ETA. More autonomy has been aspired to by the Basque and Catalan regions in particular; this wish has been shaped by the ETA's previous support of independence movements. Impact on Political Landscape: The existence of ETA has prompted the rise of political groups in Spain that support regional autonomy, such as Catalan pro-independence parties and the Basque Nationalist Party (PNV). Due to their emphasis on decentralization and self-determination, these parties have had a major impact on Spanish politics.

A case study will be utilized to examine the subject of this essay. A case study offers great flexibility when it comes to sources from different means while giving space for cross-examining the relationship between different factors like ETA’s political ideology, international cooperation, historical context, and public opinion.

**Tilly’s Functions of the State **

Tilly breaks down the main roles of the state into four distinct groups in his analysis: "war making," "state making" "protection," and "extraction." 'War making' refers to the state's capacity to fight external enemies, whereas 'State Making' denotes the state's capacity to deal with internal dangers. 'Extraction' refers to the state's ability to obtain the resources required to fund the first three duties, whilst 'Protection' emphasizes the state's responsibility to protect its residents or clients. Different kinds of states may arise as a result of the historical evolution of certain state functions. Authoritarian states tend to be more authoritarian due to a historical concentration on "War Making" and "State Making" rather than "Protection" and "Extraction." It's important to remember that there is plenty of variation in this area because regimes that are dictatorial can also heavily emphasize state development and warfare also has these characteristics. Democratic states, on the other hand, place more emphasis on "extraction" and "protection," promoting the rule of law and individual rights in the process, which results in open and accountable governmental structures. Welfare states prioritize "State Making" and "Protection," which results in the creation of substantial public services and social safety nets. Conversely, failed nations frequently find themselves in precarious situations where "War Making" and "Extraction" become imperative in order to save the state, leaving them vulnerable and unstable. The balance between the four main governmental functions has changed considerably over Spain's complicated historical development, influencing the nature of its representative democracy today. A string of conflicts and conquests, such as the Reconquista (the Christian reconquest of the Iberian Peninsula from the Moors) and Spanish colonization of the Americas, characterize Spain's history (Burguera, 2004). These historical occurrences, which called for substantial military resources and efforts, strongly highlighted the state's ability to "make war." Power consolidation and the establishment of a single Spanish state were made possible in large part by the Reconquista. The union of the several Spanish kingdoms and the start of state consolidation were symbolized by Ferdinand of Aragon and Isabella of Castile's marriage in 1469 (Remensnyder, 2005). Despite the diverse nature of the Iberian peninsula, for the time being, the state was capable of holding its various regional groups together under one banner. Authoritarian regimes came to power in Spain several times, first under the Habsburgs and then under the Franco dictatorship (Burguera, 2004). 'State Making' and 'War Making' were prioritized over 'Protection' and 'Extraction,' resulting in a more autocratic society and state. Particularly the Franco era left a significant impact on the way Spain dealt with its history and the way it turned away from prioritizing war and state making. However, it could be argued that state making was nowhere near as effective during the Franco era, as demonstrated by the excessive activities of the ETA terrorist group from the Basque Country, alongside several other smaller groups from different regional separatist movements (Edles, 1999). To a great extent, the failures of the state making of the Franco era could be attributed to the revival of Catalonian independence movements following the transition to the democracy of Spain. In the late 20th century, Spain had a democratic transition after General Franco's death in 1975 (Edles, 1999). A representative democracy was established during this shift. The Spanish Constitution of 1978 established the framework for democratic government (Edles, 1999). In contemporary Spain, the focus is on "Extraction," "Protection," and democratic ideals. Reflecting a shift towards 'Extraction' and 'Protection' functions, the nation has built robust democratic institutions, a multiparty system, and a dedication to the rule of law. With a focus on "Protection" and social safety nets, Spain has also established a welfare state where its residents have access to social welfare programs, healthcare, and education, and a high degree of labor protection (Ferrera, 2005).

**Basque Separatism and the Franco Era **

The Basque separatist organization ETA was a significant but complicated player in Spain during the Franco era. Aspirations for self-determination and regional identities were suppressed by Francisco Franco's authoritarian dictatorship, particularly in areas such as the Basque Country. This oppressive atmosphere gave rise to ETA, whose creation in the late 1950s symbolized resistance to the extremely centralized and authoritarian structure of Franco's authority (Edles, 1999). The past struggles of the Basque people to establish their unique cultural and linguistic identity served as a strong foundation for the group's fight for Basque independence. The ETA opposed the government by participating in both violent and nonviolent acts of resistance while promoting Basque sovereignty and self-determination (Edles, 1999). The group carried out bombings, assassinations, and kidnappings, which caused an abundance of instability and fear all over the country. The existence of the ETA acted as a bulwark against Franco's attempts to suppress regional identities and preserve a united Spain under a strict central government from Madrid. By emphasizing the diversity and ambitions for autonomy of the Basque Country, ETA's presence contradicted Franco's vision of a homogenous Spain. Arguably, the ETA contributed to preparing the groundwork for the post-Franco era, where Spain embraced democracy and provided its regions with more autonomy. Even though ETA's methods and use of violence were divisive and frequently denounced, the organization's historical significance as a representation of Basque identity and resistance is essential to understanding Spain's complicated past and the development of its democratic system.

**ETA’s influence on Spanish Political Culture **

Between 1959 and 2018, Spain saw significant political changes, with particular attention being paid to the role that the Basque separatist group ETA played. This essay seeks to examine the complex effects of ETA's activities on the political culture in the Basque Country during key historical periods to shed light on how political participation and attitudes have changed in response to the group's actions. Since the end of the Spanish Civil War in 1939, the Franco regime maintained a highly centralized and autocratic form of government, until 1975. This resulted in harsh political repression in the Basque Country and helped to foster a subject political culture (Almond & Verba, 1963). Citizens were politically disenfranchised and passive in this setting, which prepared the ground for later events during ETA's rise to power (Burguera, 2004). When ETA first appeared in the late 1950s, it was promoting a violently independent Basque state, away from the centralized power of Madrid. During this time, there were numerous bombings, killings, and kidnappings that not only created a pervasive atmosphere of fear but also shaped the Basque Country's political culture. The uncertainty surrounding the conflict and the fear of retaliation may have deterred citizens from actively engaging in politics, allowing for the creation of a more violent approach (Edles, 1999). Interestingly, the political climate of the 1980s and early 90s was further shaken, since the fall of the Franco regime, only accelerated the attacks carried out by ETA. In the Basque Country, where residents were dealing with the constant threat of violence and a divisive political environment, the battle between ETA and Spanish security forces had a noticeable effect on political engagement. Throughout this time, political participation and the anxiety brought on by the ongoing conflict were carefully balanced (Edles, 1999). The Basque Country's complicated political landscape shaped the events of the ensuing years. People were divided about whether to support Basque nationalism or oppose ETA's use of violence. People began to engage in politics in a more complex way as a result of this dynamic, navigating the complexities of the conflict and looking for opportunities for meaningful engagement. A turning point was reached when ETA declared in 2011 that it would stop its armed campaign and then dissolved in 2018 (Aizpeolea et al., 2021). The post-ETA period, marked by a noticeable decline in violence, offered the Basque Country a critical chance to reassess its political culture. As the region tries to make peace with its turbulent past and welcome a new era of political engagement, this time offers promise for a possible shift towards a more participatory and stable political environment (Aizpeolea et al., 2021). Noticeably, the political structure of the Basque region seems to have alternated in several ways. One key part is the urban-rural divide working differently than the rest of Spain. Where the urban populations of Bilbao and its surrounding areas vote for the center-right Basque Nationalist Party, or PNV, while the more rural areas have a larger support for the center-left PSOE. However, one could argue that this is also influenced by the PSOE’s recently more pragmatic approach towards independence movements, as highlighted by their approach to Catalan independence (Jones, 2023).
As a reminder of the difficulties presented by separatist movements and the significance of resolving regional concerns within the confines of a united and democratic nation, the legacy of ETA remains resonant in Spain's political culture. One might argue that such a history has had a great influence on the current political climate of Spain. The nation is divided into many areas, each with its own unique character, language, and culture. Among other places, the Basque Country and Catalonia are home to thriving nationalist movements that aim to achieve increased independence or autonomy. The importance of regional parties in politics reflects this regional variety and further complicates the national political scene. Spain was ruled by two major political parties for many years: the People's Party (PP) the center-right party, and the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party (PSOE) the center-left party. However, with the advent of fresh actors like Ciudadanos, a liberal party and Podemos, a more left-wing populist party, the political landscape saw a paradigm shift (Orriols & Cordero, 2016). By upending the established duopoly, this diversification gave Spanish politics a boost and reflected shifting public tastes (Orriols & Cordero, 2016). However, the emergence of Vox, a far-right political party in Spain, has had a significant impact on the political landscape of the nation. The rise of Vox poses a threat to the established political spectrum, which is dominated by the center-left and center-right parties. Vox was founded in 2013 and has experienced notable growth in the elections that followed, especially in the Andalusian regional election of 2018 and the national election of 2019 (Mendes & Dennison, 2020). Strong nationalism, anti-immigration beliefs, and hostility to regional autonomy movements define Vox's political agenda (Mendes & Dennison, 2020). Its ascent represents a movement within some segments of the Spanish electorate towards more conservative and nationalist ideologies (Mendes & Dennison, 2020). Vox's success has led to a reassessment of Spain's political climate, which has exacerbated division. Vox's presence underscores the increasingly complex political culture of Spain, as the country's voters express a wide range of sometimes divergent opinions on topics like immigration, national identity, and the proper balance between central and regional powers. Vox continues to have a significant impact on political discourse and policy debates. The past of the ETA highlights the development of political culture in the Basque Country but also highlights the wide-ranging and substantial influence that violence has had in the region. This influence is especially significant in light of the intricate connection, in the particular Basque context, between political developments and citizen engagement. This commenced with the political culture that was prevalent under Franco's rule, where people were politically disenfranchised and passive. From there, it moves into the turbulent period that was characterized by ETA's violent actions. The political climate of this era was defined by the complex interaction between political engagement, fear, and the quest for a distinctive Basque state. A more nuanced form of political participation emerged as the Basques worked through the difficulties of endorsing or rejecting ETA's tactics, one that reflected the fine balance needed during a conflict. The final period, which began with ETA declaring an end to its armed campaign and dissolving eventually, signifies more than just the end of violence; it also offers hope for a different future for the Basque Country. This post-ETA era presents a chance for the region to move towards a more stable, inclusive, and cooperative political environment by providing a blank canvas for a reevaluation of political culture. Therefore, these historical periods represent the possibility of resilience, development, and a revitalized civic culture in the post-conflict environment.

Assertive Citizenship in Post-ETA Spain

Spain has experienced significant changes in its democratic governance and citizenship environment in recent decades. By using the works of Inglehart and Sen as a guide, we may identify important trends that have influenced the nation's political engagement and culture. Sen places a strong emphasis on the inherent worth of freedom, equality, and personal responsibility in his conception of democracy. He contends that democracy encompasses more than just formal procedures and includes real freedoms and opportunities, such access to healthcare, education, and the economy. Sen's paradigm emphasizes how crucial it is to advance human development and well-being as primary objectives of democratic government. According to Inglehart's theory of postmaterialism, postmaterialist ideals like self-expression, autonomy, and quality of life replace materialistic ones when countries modernize and experience economic growth. Following Franco's rule, Spain went from a dictatorship to a functional democracy, and these changes were accompanied by broader social and economic shifts such as increasing prosperity, rapid urbanization, and an increase in education. These shifts have aided in the rise of postmaterialist values among urban residents and younger generations, who place a higher priority on matters like gender equality, cultural diversity, and environmental sustainability. There are significant ramifications for political engagement in Spain from these changes in democratic citizenship and governance. Voting and party membership are examples of traditional political engagement; more recent types of activism include community-based projects, digital lobbying, and grassroots organizing. The emergence of assertive citizenship has given common people the ability to oppose established power structures, hold government agencies accountable and transparent, and support progressive causes. In modern Spain, the dynamics of assertive citizenship interact with the legacy of ETA's terrorism. As a result of the decades-long campaign against the violence of ETA, people became more resilient and engaged in society, uniting to denounce terrorism, promote peace, and uphold democratic principles. The terror campaign carried out by ETA inspired civil society, resulting in large-scale demonstrations, grassroots initiatives, and appeals for peace. Although the violence of ETA aimed to weaken democratic values and social unity, it unintentionally made Spanish people more determined to defend the rule of law, encourage communication, and protect human rights. The way that the Spanish people have responded to the terrorism of ETA shows how resilient Spanish democracy is and how powerful assertive citizenship can be when it comes to facing threats to democratic government. Such resilient assertive citizenry will be tested as both Spain and Europe are seeing a rise in far right parties.

Bibliography

Almond, G. A., & Verba, S. (1963). The civic Culture: political attitudes and democracy in five nations. http://ci.nii.ac.jp/ncid/BA10223978 Aizpeolea, L. R., Aizpeolea, L. R., & Aizpeolea, L. R. (2021, October 20). The end of Basque terror group ETA: ‘It was unilateral, clean and without trade-offs.’ EL PAÍS English. https://english.elpais.com/spain/2021-10-20/the-end-of-basque-terror-group-eta-it-was-unilateral-clean-and-without-trade-offs.html#:~:text=October%2020%2C%202011.,gang%20announces%20its%20definitive%20dissolution. Burguera, M., & Schmidt‐Nowara, C. (2004). Backwardness and its discontents. Social History, 29, 279 - 283. https://doi.org/10.1080/0307102042000257484. Edles, L. (1999). A Culturalist Approach to Ethnic Nationalist Movements: Symbolization and Basque and Catalan Nationalism in Spain. Social Science History, 23, 311 - 355. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0145553200018113. Ferrera, M. (2005). Welfare State Reform In Southern Europe Fighting Poverty And Social Exclusion In Italy, Spain, Portugal, And Greece. . https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203356906. Gerring, J. (2004). What Is a Case Study and What Is It Good for? American Political Science Review, 98(2), 341–354. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0003055404001182 Jones, S. (2023, November 7). Socialist party members in Spain back deal to secure PM new term. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/nov/05/psoe-members-back-catalan-amnesty-plan-to-secure-power-in-spain Lijphart, A. (1971). Comparative Politics and the Comparative Method. The American Political Science Review, 65(3), 682–693. https://doi.org/10.2307/1955513 Mendes, M. S., & Dennison, J. (2020). Explaining the emergence of the radical right in Spain and Portugal: salience, stigma and supply. West European Politics, 44(4), 752–775. https://doi.org/10.1080/01402382.2020.1777504 Orriols, L., & Cordero, G. (2016). The breakdown of the Spanish Two-Party system: the upsurge of Podemos and Ciudadanos in the 2015 general election. South European Society and Politics, 21(4), 469–492. https://doi.org/10.1080/13608746.2016.1198454 Remensnyder, A. (2005). Reconquest and Crusade in Medieval Spain. Speculum, 938-939. https://doi.org/10.5860/choice.40-6649. Tilly, C. (1985). War making and state making as organized crime. In Cambridge University Press eBooks (pp. 169–191). https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511628283.008 Sen, A. (2004). Elements of a theory of human rights. Philosophy & Public Affairs, 32(4), 315–356. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1088-4963.2004.00017.x Stecker, C. (2020). Norris, Pippa, und Ronald Inglehart (2019): Cultural Backlash. Trump, Brexit, and Authoritarian Populism. Politische Vierteljahresschrift, 61(2), 389–391. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11615-020-00246-2